Matthew Lillard

Actor known for playing Stu Macher in Scream and Shaggy Rogers in Scooby-Doo · Entertainment - Film & Television

Scream Franchise / Wes Craven Productions

Matthew Lillard

Era

Modern Era - Circa 2011-2020

Item Type

Blu-ray Disc Cover Art

Condition

Excellent; signature is bold and vibrant with no fading, though there is minor surface smudging on the plastic sleeve.

Rarity

Moderate; Lillard is a frequent signer at conventions but his autographs remain in high demand due to cult fandom.

Overall Assessment

A quintessential 'Scream' collectible featuring a high-quality, bold signature from a fan-favorite actor on an appropriate franchise medium.

Authenticity Assessment

Highly likely authentic; confidence level 95%

Signature Style

Stylized shorthand 'M Lillard' with an aggressive, vertical 'M' loop and a sharp trailing horizontal finish.

Signature Characteristics

High-velocity strokes, consistent slant to the right, and the signature 'v' shape in the middle representing the transition from first to last name.

Ink & Medium

Orange/Copper metallic paint pen on plastic Blu-ray cover slick.

Item Description

2011 Scream 4 / Scream Trilogy Blu-ray cover featuring the Ghostface mask and lead cast members.

Estimated Value

$60.00 - $100.00 USD

Comparison to Known Examples

Matches standard convention-signed exemplars from the late 2010s perfectly in flow and scale.

Authentication Tips

Look for the distinct 'loop-back' on the initial M and the way the 'L' blends into a jagged horizontal line typical of his high-speed convention signings.

Certification Recommendation

Beckett Authentication Services (BAS) or JSA (James Spence Authentication).

Red Flags

No significant red flags observed; pen pressure and stroke overlap are consistent with genuine hand-signing.

Provenance Notes

Likely obtained at a horror convention (e.g., Monster-Mania or Spooky Empire); look for matching COA stickers from the event organizers.

Historical Context

Matthew Lillard's performance in the 1996 original 'Scream' defined the 'horror-comedy' energy of the 90s, making him a cornerstone of the genre.

Market Trends

Stable to slightly appreciating; Scream memorabilia has seen a pricing surge following the 2022 and 2023 franchise revivals.

Investment Potential

Moderate/Stable; a solid mid-tier collectible that holds value well among horror enthusiasts.

Similar Autographs

Neve Campbell, Skeet Ulrich, David Arquette, Courteney Cox.

Display & Preservation

Keep out of direct sunlight to prevent the metallic ink from dulling; use a UV-protected Blu-ray display case.

Interesting Facts

Lillard is known for being extremely friendly at signings and often uses colorful paint pens that contrast with the dark backgrounds of horror posters.

Identified on 6/10/2026